St. Petersburg Times food critic L Reiley awards Square One Burgers 'Best Burger in Tampa Bay'
![]()
Reviews / Videos / Articles
- Grilled Cheese Takes Center Stage
The humble grilled cheese gets a necessary elevation.
- Back to basics
Veteran restaurateur returns to his roots with upscale burger concept
- Gulf Coast Business Review
Squared Away by Carl Cronan
- How travel costs affect food prices: « View PDF of the article from My Fox News Tampa Bay
- SRQ Daily - HUNTING & GATHERING
[Good Bite] Three Mushroom Boom
Ashton Goggans, ashton.goggans@srqmediagroup.comSquare 1 Burgers has all types of interesting things to throw between burger buns, from ostrich and buffalo to the three mushroom burger, which slides a portobello, porcini and garden mushroom sauté onto a whole wheat bun with melted Gruyére cheese and Sooner sauce. All burgers come with choice of fries, slaw or broccoli, which can be substituted for sweet potato fries, fried jalapenos or mac 'n' cheese, for a bit more. Share:
Square 1 Burgers and Bar, 1737 South Tamiami Trl., Sarasota, 941-870-8111; 5239 University Pkwy., Sarasota, 941-359-0001
- Square's the Beef - March, 2011 by: SARASOTA MAGAZINE - John Bancroft
We're fond of gazing at the bar, and this is a good spot for it...." - Comfort and Contrast - YourObserver.com - December 29, 2010 by: Molly Schechter | Food Editor
"They call it “cowboy chic.” “Sexy saloon” would be another option, given features that range from deco echo chairs with pony-upholstered seats to an astounding red chandelier hanging over a corner booth — worth a visit in and of itself. It is the menu, however, that is most intriguing. Jack and Mrs. Spratt could eat here together on options that range from flat-out comfort foot to happily healthful."
There are mini cupcakes to tempt the Jack Sprats and cupcake sundaes with an Italian-inspired, espresso-scented Chocolate “Zuppa” for his Mrs.
- Metromix.com
"Also, try some of their amazing sauces. You can't go wrong with sun-dried tomato mayo or teriyaki ginger sauce."
- St. Petersburg Times
"He and partner Joanie Corneil, who opened Hyde Park standby Bella's Italian Cafe 21 years ago, are getting into the burger business. And their Square One Burgers will be anything but typical."
"Well, except for being round. "Everyone always asks me that," Shumate said with a chuckle." - Tampa Bay Online
"Much has been made of Square One's "Decadent" burger, a $13.99 Kobe beef patty. It's worth every penny. The thick burger comes topped with carmelized onions, lettuce, a generous slice of Brie cheese and sun-dried tomato mayonnaise."
- TBO Extra
"Square One Burgers aims to be different and succeeds. This is no fast food joint -- more like a trendy, upscale diner."
- Urban Spoon
"I'm sad that I haven't tried Square One Burgers any sooner than today... I surely have been missing out! I was a little overwhelmed at creating my own burger so I opted for the Buffalo Bob specialty burger. This glorious beast consisted of buffalo meat, beer cheese sauce, fried onion rings, and smoked applewood bacon. Yeah, yeah... not too healthy, but DAMN it was good!!!"
- Wordpress
- Yelp
"THAT WAS ONE OF THE BEST BURGERS THAT I HAVE EVER HAD!!! The order of fries was huge and they were soooo good...seasoned perfectly."

